(yes those are goosebumps..it was cold outside haha)
This isnt a palette I would normally have picked up for myself. My hubbs actually got this as a gift for me on Halloween. When I first saw the colors I was like "Ohhhh..I can use these alone..the black as a liner..". However, when I got around to swatching, I was disappointed. Where The Temptress's Gaze was buttery, and nicely pigmented, this was chalky, and sheer. All the colors, with the exception of the navy blueish shade on the bottom right, were all sheer, and I had to swipe the applicator 3/4x to get any colors to show up. The green was the most sheer though. The two blue shades, I was also super sad about.. Swatched the dark blue looks like a charcoal with a slight blue duochrome. Its super subtle and unless you're looking hard, you can barely tell. The brighter blue (bottom left) also isnt as bright and as vibrant as it looks in the pan. *Sad face..*
Overall, I'm disappointed. The colors aren't cohesive (I cant imagine using these all at once..), and they're chalky and sheer. I will probably use the purple, and the blue (bottom left) , with primer but that's about it. I cant attest to the staying power, as I haven't tried these on my eyes yet. If you run across this, I'd probably say pass..